You’ve completed the requirements, finished your service hours, and wrapped up your Scoutmaster conference ( if you haven’t finished that yet, check out our guide here!). Now there’s just one thing left: the Board of Review.
It’s completely normal to feel a little nervous — but don’t worry. A Board of Review isn’t a test, and no one is trying to trick you. It’s a conversation about your growth, your experiences, and your next steps in Scouting.
In this guide, we’ll explain what a Board of Review is, what to expect, how to prepare, and how to walk in with confidence.
What Is a Board of Review?
A Board of Review (BOR) is a required step for every rank in Scouts BSA from Tenderfoot to Eagle Scout. Its purpose is to:
- Confirm that you’ve completed all the requirements
- Give you a chance to reflect on what you’ve learned
- Hear about your experiences and growth
- Offer encouragement for your next steps
A typical board includes three to six adult troop committee members (not your Scoutmaster or parents), and usually lasts about 15 to 30 minutes, depending on the rank.
What a Board of Review Is Not
It’s not:
- A retest of merit badge knowledge
- A pop quiz on Scout skills
- Something to fear
You’ve already completed the requirements. The Board of Review is your chance to share your story and show who you are as a Scout.
What to Expect at a Board of Review
Before the Board:
- You’ll be called in by a committee member
- Adults will welcome you and explain the purpose
- They may review your advancement records or handbook
During the Board:
- You’ll be asked questions about your experience in Scouting
- You’ll reflect on your troop participation, leadership, service, and what you’ve learned
- You’ll be encouraged to share challenges and successes
After the Board:
- You may be asked to step out briefly
- The board will discuss and then call you back in
- If approved, they’ll congratulate you and share some feedback
How to Prepare (and Not Be Nervous)
1. Know Your Journey
Be ready to talk about:
- When you joined the troop
- What activities you’ve enjoyed
- What challenges you’ve overcome
- How you’ve helped others
You don’t need to memorize dates or ranks — just reflect on your personal experience.
2. Think About the Scout Oath and Law
You may be asked how you live out Scouting values. Pick real-life examples that show how you’ve been trustworthy, helpful, courteous, or kind at school, at home, or in the troop.
3. Practice with a Parent or Leader
Have someone do a mock Board of Review with you. Practice sitting up straight, making eye contact, and answering questions clearly and calmly.
4. Dress Neatly
Wear your full Scout uniform — shirt tucked in, merit badge sash (if applicable), neckerchief, and clean pants. First impressions matter, and showing pride in your uniform helps set the tone.
5. Remember: Everyone Wants You to Succeed
The adults in the room are there to support and encourage you, not to catch you off guard. They want to see you succeed and grow.
Sample Questions You Might Be Asked
Here are some common questions asked during Boards of Review, especially for Star, Life, and Eagle:
General Experience
- What’s your favorite part about being in the troop?
- What’s the most challenging requirement you’ve completed?
- How have you grown as a Scout since your last rank?
Leadership & Service
- What position of responsibility did you hold, and what did you learn?
- Tell us about a time you helped another Scout.
- What kind of service did you do, and what impact did it have?
Scout Spirit
- How do you live the Scout Oath and Law outside of Scouting?
- What does “A Scout is Loyal” mean to you?
- Have you ever had to make a hard decision that tested your values?
Looking Forward
- What goals do you have in Scouting?
- Are you thinking about working toward Eagle Scout?
- What would you say to a new Scout just starting out?
Encouragement for Every Scout
It’s completely normal to feel a little nervous. But remember — by the time you’re at a Board of Review, you’ve already:
- Completed every requirement
- Served your troop and community
- Grown as a leader
- Learned real, valuable skills
That’s something to be proud of.
Speak honestly, take your time answering questions, and don’t be afraid to share your real thoughts. You don’t have to be perfect — just be your best self.
Final Thoughts
Your Board of Review is a moment to pause and reflect on how far you’ve come in Scouting. It’s a milestone — and a reminder that advancement is about more than badges. It’s about character, service, leadership, and personal growth.
Walk in with confidence. You’ve already done the work — now it’s time to celebrate it.
